I had already posted that. But someone telled me that proposals ary only accept in the blog, so I'm doing this now. This is my first proposal, and english is not my language, so forgive me for any mistake.
Where is she from? Scarlet Lady, a Miraculous Ladybug AU where Chloé uses the Ladybug Miraculous, being the "heroine" Scarlet Lady.
Who is she? An alternate version of the original Lila Rossi, who was humiliated by Scarlet Lady, but after an argument with Marinette, decided not to run away from school and make friends by being honest.
What makes her admirable?[]
- Even when she lied, it is revealed that she had a reason for it: because her family moved a lot, she never had time to form friendships properly, and began lying as a way to defend herself and make friends more easily. This is shown as a form of sympathy for the character.
- Unlike her grudge against Ladybug in canon, her grudge against Scarlet Lady is less petty and much more understandable, considering Scarlet threw her in a fountain and ridiculed her for being a liar in front of not just Adrien, but all of her friends. and classmates - even laughing about it - to the point of making her cry, which makes her kind of sympathetic.
- She is much more heroic and honorable than her canon villainous counterpart, as she did not become a villain and is friends with Marinette, and no longer uses lies to get what she wants.
- She apologizes to her colleagues for her lies.
- Even as an akumatized villain, she shows some standards, being horrified and furious to see that the Scarlet Lady is willing to let civilians - including Adrien - die during battles.
- She acts as Manon's temporary babysitter so she can buy Miss Bustier a birthday present.
- She is furious with Scarlet Lady for being willing to let Alya drown and expresses relief to see that she is okay.
- She shows concern for Sabrina when she is infected by Zombizou.
- She praises Sabrina for her helpfulness and observation skills, calling these characteristics worthy of a true heroine.
- She protects Adrien from Frightningale, stating that just because they don't get along doesn't mean she would let him get caught by an Akuma.
- She helps the heroes defeat Frightningale, being a key player in defeating her.
- On Heroes' Day, she, Sabrina and Alix defend Zoé and try to protect the heroes' reputation.
- In their most emotional moment, she and Sabrina apologize to Alix/Timebreaker for not realizing her insecurities and helping her with her fears, calling her a great friend they won't leave behind.
- She and the other heroes help Ladybug and Chat Noir defeat Hawk Moth.
- While it could be argued that she does not meet this AU's admirable standards, that is not the case, as she did most of the actions listed - including saving Adrien - while she was just an ordinary schoolgirl without Miraculous, and in the short period in which she She was a hero, she was very important in defeating an Akuma, saved Ladybug and Chat Noir and helped in the fight against Hawk Moth.
What makes her inconsistent?[]
- She's an asshole: Having confessed to Marinette that he gave her a mask as a gift just because he wanted to get rid of it because it reminded her of Scarlet; Having insinuated that she intended to tell the same lies as in canon when she became friends with Sabrina, saying that she would leave her homework in her hands; taking advantage of the fact that Chloé is covered in rubbish to take humiliating photos of her; proposing to destroy Chloé's hotel when everyone was called to her party and mocking Frightningale when confronting her.
- She is very arrogant, likes "morning compliments" just to hear them and when she is attacked by a zombified Sabrina, she says it's not time to realize how amazing she is.
- Although she stands out enough to not be a Benchmark Hero, she still fails to meet heroic standards compared to Cat Noir and Marigold, who are much more heroic and save the day more times than her.
- While her grudge against Scarlet Lady is understandable, she is too vengeful and sadistic to be PG or NPG; humiliating her live on Nadja Chamack's show and wanting to find a way to use the Rooster's power to replace her. While it's understandable given what a poor example of a hero Scarlet is, her attitudes are too vindictive for her to be anything more than Inconsistently Admirable.
Final vote?
- It depends on you.
Other links: