Mr. Butter is the main protagonist of the trendy action comedy YouTube channel Buttered Side Down. He is an extremely comedic on and off dimwitted inventor who creates very sophisticated inventions to solve his very basic problems, but often has to deal with them going extremely wrong. He ends up committing very admirable and very heinous acts all the time, sometimes on purpose and sometimes not.
His Good Ranking[]
What Makes Him Admirable?[]
- When he decides to be a hero, he does use all the resources he has to do all he can (although, it's the same thing for when he's a villain).
- In "Pet Rock 2," he risked his life to collect lightning to save Pet Rock, and did a bunch of other (sometimes shady) acts to save him, such as duct taping him together, slaughtering a unicorn for glitter, building a robot machine for him, squashing a green blob from space, and kidnapping the Staff of Unspeakable Evil. As Pet Rock came alive, Mr. Butter is thrilled and they go on more adventures, even though Mr. Butter's entire house had been destroyed. Also, he became very concerned and looked for Pet Rock after he went missing in "Losing Pet Rock," even making a toy pet rock to make himself feel better.
- In "Eating Something Spicy," he accidentally caused the planets to come towards Earth when he stole the sun for his spicy noodles experiment, but put the sun back and saved the world. (although, right after that, he accidentally burned down the entire city with his fire breath, and was apathetic.)
- In "Solving A Crime," he went on a detective mission to find out who stole his valuable diamond.
- In "Learning to Golf," after finding a hostile squirrel, he made friends with it and the squirrel taught him how to golf. When the squirrel is carried off by a hawk, Mr. Butter saves his friend by swinging a golf ball at the hawk, killing it (pretty extremist but that's how nature works).
- In "Learning to Play Tennis," after his tennis ball shooting machine he made to play tennis with himself starts to have a mind of its own and massacres people, Mr. Butter fights his creation with his super tennis racket and wins the fight, even redeeming the machine, but suddenly not caring about corpses and fires all around him (bad man).
- In "Doing the Dishes," he accidentally makes a black hole sponge that eats everything around it, including cars and people, so he throws the sponge into the ocean to protect everyone, but ends up getting eaten himself.
- In "Saving the World," he did his best act, where he used his new Welch's Fruit Snacks superpowers to turn a meteor into a squishy fruit, saving the city, a truck stuck on the train tracks into a pile of fruit, saving the train (and making a mess), caught a getaway criminal driver in a piece of fruit for the cops to arrest them, turned alien ships shooting lasers at the city into harmless fruit snacks, saved a skydiver who forgot his parachute by landing him on a squishy fruit and feeding him, and finally gives the superpowers to a little girl who turns the moon into fruit (which was cute).
- In "Making Ice Cream," he reluctantly raised an ice cream cone as his own son, with some love, even though he wanted to eat it (eventually he becomes heinous and does take a bite of him).
- In "Making A Movie," he gave a random homeless man a job in acting, however the heroic deed is ruined when Mr. Butter's squirrel burned the man alive with a flamethrower, and Mr. Butter liked the special effect.
- In "Giant Vacuum," as the real Mr. Butter is vacuuming up an entire imaginary town in his rug, the rug Mr. Butter grabs an axe and cuts the wire to save the city, but when that doesn't work (because duct tape), he precariously climbs the wire a mile high and jumps, falling all the way to the ground and cutting the entire vacuum bag open to save the city again (then loses to the Eureka robot vacuum). (Ironically, Mr. Butter is admirable and heinous at the exact same time in this episode.)
- In "3000 Mile Delivery," although not exactly heroic, he walks 1701 miles through land and swims 809 miles through the ocean simply to deliver a pie.
What Makes Him Inconsistent?[]
- He is Inconsistently Heinous for his long list of heinous deeds. He is both a hero by proxy and a villain by proxy and pretty much Pure Chaotic Neutral, always going with the flow of the insane chaos of each episode, constantly changing his mind over being good and being evil.
- He has an extraordinarily massive kill count, mutilation count, and fates-worse-than-death count, and nearly every episode adds a huge number to them.
- There are several episodes where he's neither a hero nor a villain.
- He is so incredibly dimwitted and mentally ill that he has only partial moral agency, and is extremely incompetent and has little control over his chaotic inventions.
- He betrays his own friends all the time, sometimes killing them or even giving them a fate worse than death for a thing they don't deserve.
- He usually feels apathy over his terrible crimes, but sometimes he shows remorse.
- He's a hypocrite and has disciplined many people for doing the same crimes he does.
- He mutilated a multitude of innocent pumpkins in "Carving A Pumpkin," lightbulbs in "Changing A Light Bulb," living things in "Learning to Draw," his ice cream son in "Making Ice Cream," and even himself in "Playing Tic Tac Toe."
- He's caused fires and explosions in civilian areas in many episodes, and even vacuumed up hundreds of houses in "Giant Vacuum."
- He attacked his teacher in "Learning the Violin," abused his vacuum cleaner in "Vacuuming A Mess," feeding it dangerous objects, and treated The Staff of Unspeakable Evil like a slave in the episode of the same name.
- He overreacted to a spider in "Killing A Spider," and burned down his whole house to kill the spider's family. He did a similar thing in "Swatting A Fly."
- He gave himself a 1 million dollar tip in "3000 Mile Delivery" even though the customer died waiting for him. He killed multiple animals and people in the same episode, and threw a villainous car into a neighborhood.
Trivia[]
- He has literally fought against himself multiple times due to magical events in episodes, and he seems to be his own worst enemy.
External Links[]
- Mr. Butter on the Heroes Fanon Wiki
- Mr. Butter on the Villains Fanon Wiki
- Mr. Butter on the Inconsistently Heinous Wiki
- Mr. Butter on the Buttered Side Down Wiki