This page is dedicated for heroes who are considered not admirable enough to meet the baseline standard of the work they're in while also being too generic.
Outside of Pure Good and Near Pure Good, the other categories that are not listed as Inconsistently Admirable are as follows.
Standard Good: Heroes who are standard good can never qualify as most of their heroism is too generic. In theory, they have the personality to qualify for either Pure Good or Near Pure Good as they're genuinely nice and friendly people. In practice, however, they often don't have the heroism to back it up.
Conflicting Good: Characters that have a hard time even being called heroic.
Heroes
Standard Good
- Akeno Himejima: Fails the admirable standards of High School DxD to Asia Argento and Issei Hyodou.
- Beat (Jet Set Radio): Generic "save the world" and "undo the brainwashing" hero.
- Benson Dunwoody: Fails the admirable standard of Regular Show.
- Bob Bobowski: Mario defeated omnicidal maniacs with similar resources and SMG3 redeemed Waluigi.
- BoJack Horseman: Fails to stand out compared to Todd, Mr. Peanutbutter and Diane.
- Bowser Jr.: Fails the admirable standards of Super Mario Bros. franchise.
- Cassandra Alexandra: Fails the admirable standards compared to several characters like her older sister Sophitia and Siegfried.
- Catelyn Stark (Game of Thrones): Fails the admirable standards compared to her husband Ned.
- Cosmo and Wanda: Fails the admirable standards compared to both Timmy and Jorgen.
- Cuphead (The Cuphead Show!): His role in saving souls are too indirect to count, which prevents him from being compared to his brother Mugman.
- Dale Gribble: Bog-standard nice guy.
- David García: Self-sacrifice and protecting people are generic actions for The Walking Dead franchise and he also fails the admirable standards as well.
- David Xanatos: Fails the admirable standards of Gargoyles to Dingo and Emir.
- Driver (Drive): Everything he ever did throughout the movie is just bog-standard.
- Ed (Ed, Edd n Eddy): Generic life saver.
- Emily Davis: Fails the heinous standards of Until Dawn compared to Mike and Sam.
- Fender Pinwheeler: Failed to stands out compared to Rodney Copperbottom.
- Greg Heffley: Aside from being bog-standard, he fails the admirable standards to his younger brother Manny who saved hundreds of lives.
- Han Mi-nyeo: Most of her acts are self-serving, and the few that aren't are merely warning a player and praising two other players.
- Henry Hill: He sounds too standard and wasn't admirable as he is.
- Hodoka Morishima: Fails the admirable standars to Hina who tried to sacrifice herself to save everyone.
- Igor (Persona): Fails to stand out alongside other major characters in the franchise.
- Ironhide (Bayverse): Fails the admirable standards of Transformers film series.
- Kaname Ohgi: Fails the admirable standard of Code Geass.
- King Olly: Fails the admirable standards of the Paper Mario series too much since he only does one heroic thing.
- Lamar Davis: Fails the admirable standards of Grand Theft Auto V compared with Michael, Franklin, Lester and even Trevor.
- Lenny Feder and Eric Lamonsoff: Their greatest actions are standing up to the bullies, which is bog-standard.
- Lilly Scott: Like Dodo, her bog-standard heroism is nothing more than generic kindness.
- Lois Griffin: Fails the admirable standard of Family Guy compared to Brian.
- Lord Business: Him redeeming himself and freeing everyone from getting frozen doesn't made him stand out compared to Emmet, Lucy and Batman who has done with much less resources than him.
- Madara Uchiha: Fails the admirable standards compared to Hashirama and Tobirama who has contributed more of forming Konoha.
- Metro Man: His heroism is offscreen and fails the admirable standards compared to Megamind who stopped Tighten; Minion who helped Megamind escape from prison to let him fight Tighten and personally fiercely fought Tighten; and Roxanne who, despite being an ordinary person, played a major role in inspiring Megamind to stop Tighten.
- Michael (Cartoon All-Stars to the Rescue): Subverted himself from his drug habit and saving two characters isn't good enough to pass the baseline.
- Min Min (ARMS): The rest of her heroic acts are just serving food and being nice to people, making her a bog-standard.
- Misa Amane: Showing kindness is just bog-standard heroism.
- Ms. Chalice (The Cuphead Show!): Fails the admirable standard compared to Cuphead and Mugman.
- Nagato: He doesn't stand out enough compared to other heroes in Naruto series.
- Nico Yazawa: Despite being too inconsistent, she is too standard to qualify.
- Otto (Despicable Me): Fails the admirable standards to Kevin and Bob.
- Painis Cupcake (TF2 Freakshow): None of his heroism did make him pass the general baseline.
- Philza (Dream SMP): Fails the admirable standard compared to TommyInnit and Technoblade.
- Puff Puff: While he saves 3 orphans from Bill Cosby, it's not enough to truly push him out of standard heroism.
- Queen Bee: Fails the admirable standard of Miraculous Ladybug.
- Rexy (Jurassic Park/World): Fails the admirable standard compared to Blue.
- Robb Stark (Game of Thrones): Fails the admirable standard compared to Arya and Tyrion.
- Rose Diaz: Aside from being standard, she fails the admirable standards of Brooklyn 99 to Jake, Holt and Terry.
- Saki Mugendo: Fails the admirable standard of Yumeutsutsu Re:Master compared to Ai and Marie.
- Sanda (War of the Gargantuas): He's just a generic bog-standard stop the villain hero.
- Shadow Bonnie: Too standard and failed the admirable standard compared to Henry Emily.
- Shane Walsh (TV Series): Fails the admirable standards of The Walking Dead.
- Silas Ramsbottom: Fails the admirable standard of Despicable Me compared to Gru, Dru, Lucy and Kevin.
- Silas Sinister: Turning Dylan back into a human is just bog-standard.
- Six (Little Nightmares): Only saving one person that didn't make her pass the baseline and everything she did is only to survive.
- Slyly: Despite being inconsistent, he is too standard to qualify.
- Squidward Tentacles: Fails to Patrick, as he didn't do anything to try to stop Plankton's slavery and thus fails to keep up with him stopping mass atrocities several times.
- Stuart (Despicable Me): Fails the admirable standards to Kevin and Bob.
- Summer (101 Dalmatians Street): Most of her heroism is too standard to qualify.
- Tabby Darklight: Fails the admirable standards of Tabbykitth's Tabbyverse.
- Tai Lung: He only dragged Chameleon into the Spirit Realm after she was defeated and powerless, which prevents him from standing out alongside Po and Zhen who played a huge part in defeating the Chameleon.
- Terrance (SMG4): Fails the admirable standards compared to Axol.
- The Unnamed Player (POV: You Meet the Unluckiest Player in Minecraft): Saving one life isn't enough to pass the general standard.
- Tilly Green: Her heroism is too standard.
- Titan Ravager (AvM Shorts): Fails the admirable standards of Animator vs. Animation series compare to other heroes such as The Second Coming, the Stick Gang, The Chosen One, the Animator and Purple.
- Trevor Phillips: Fails the admirable standards of Grand Theft Auto V compared with Michael and Franklin and his admirable deeds are only shared with them.
- Tubbo: He didn't really defeat Dream, and as a result Tommy played a more active role in general and with lesser resources.
- Waylon Smithers: Fails the admirable standards compared to Homer, Bart, Sideshow Bob, and his boss Mr. Burns, all who saved Springfield with similiar resources.
- Wayne Werewolf: Failed the admirable standards compared to Dracula, Dennis and Johnny, whom they have prominent roles of defeating major villains.
- Wednesday Addams (Calvert Hall Theater: The Addams Family): Her actions are just generic heroism.
- Wilbur Soot: Tommy played a more active role against Dream and Techno protected people and ended tyranny.
- Vecna: Fails the admirable standards of Stranger Things to Eleven.
- Victor Sullivan: Fails the admirable standard compared to Nathan Drake.
- Vinny Griffin: Doesn't do anything to pass the baseline of Family Guy.
- Zen-Aku: A bog-standard rescuer who doesn't do anything to stand out compared to Wild Force rangers.
Conflicting Good
- Arnim Zola (What If...?): Helping the heroes in defeating Infinity Ultron is nothing but out of self-serving reasons.
- Best Friend (One Night at Flumpty's): They only did nothing but survive from his game.
- Homelander (TV Series): All of his heroism are nothing but pragmatic and self-serving intentions.
- Light Yagami's Normal Self: Is a Pure Evil villain who does nothing heroic.
- The Projectionist (Bendy and the Ink Machine): His admirable acts were done completely out of his will.
- Scrat: He doesn't do anything vaguely heroic at all as most of the time he's just trying to go after his acorn.
- Soldier Boy (TV Series): Much like the Homelander, most of his heroism were nothing but self-serving.
PG/NPG Status Under Debate
- Alan Grant
- Bigwig (Watership Down 2018)
- Booster Gold (DC Animated Universe)
- Boots the Monkey
- Carmine Lupertazzi Jr.
- Catboy, Owlette and Gekko
- Chief (Dog Man)
- Dog Man
- Edmund Pevensie
- Esenia Steklova
- Fink (The Wild Robot)
- George Beard and Harold Hutchins (The Epic Tales of Captain Underpants)
- Jarrod (Power Rangers Jungle Fury)
- Jeremy the Germ
- Jessica Cruz (DC Super Hero Girls 2019)
- Lefty Enright
- Legoshi (Beastars)
- Lizzie Devine
- Manic the Hedgehog
- Maxi (Soulcalibur)
- Maximus (Gladiator)
- Nathan Algren
- Nick Russell
- Perdita (Live-Action Film)
- Petey the Cat
- Pongo (Live-Action Film)
- Sailor Venus (90s Anime)
- Sherlock Holmes (2009)
- Shinjiro Aragaki
- Stella (Angry Birds Stella TV Series)
- Susan Pevensie
- Taki (Soulcalibur)
- Traveler (Genshin Impact)
Notes
- Do not add real people to this wiki.
- Pure Good and Near Pure Good Heroes are not allowed to have profiles.
- Any heroic theology figures are NEVER allowed to have pages here due to being too controversial.